Kensink Labs
★ Content audit13 rubricsPer-type scoring
CONTENT TYPES · 13 RUBRICS

Different page types fail differently.

A homepage, a pillar page, a product page, and a knowledge-base article should never be audited against the same rubric. This is where the real wins live — and where most generic audits skip straight past. Here are the thirteen rubrics we run.

01 · BRAND · HIGH-TRAFFIC01 / 13

Home page

First impression. Must answer ‘what is this’ in under seven seconds.

Rubric
  • Value proposition understandable in ≤ 7 seconds
  • Primary CTA above the fold — one dominant action
  • Social proof (logos, testimonials, key metrics) visible without scrolling far
  • Clear routing to 3–5 primary site sections
  • Under 2.0s LCP — this is your highest-traffic page
  • Brand-query ranking: should rank #1 for your own name
Schema · Organization + WebSite
02 · PILLAR · DEFINITIVE02 / 13

Pillar / hub pages

The definitive resource on a topic. Anchors the cluster.

Rubric
  • Comprehensive coverage — aim for ‘definitive resource’ depth
  • Strong internal linking outward to cluster pages, inward from them
  • Table of contents for long-form pillars
  • Target keyword: broad, high-volume, head term
  • Last-updated date visible and recent
  • Answer-ready structure — H2s phrased as questions for key sub-topics
Schema · Article + FAQPage (where relevant)
03 · CLUSTER · LONG-TAIL03 / 13

Cluster / supporting articles

One narrow idea per article. Links to parent pillar + siblings.

Rubric
  • Narrow, specific topic — one idea per article
  • Internal link to parent pillar + sibling cluster pages
  • 800–2,500 words depending on query intent (don’t bloat)
  • Long-tail keyword focus
  • Author byline with credentials (E-E-A-T signal)
  • Published + modified dates
Schema · Article + Author (Person) + BreadcrumbList
04 · PROOF · CREDIBILITY04 / 13

Case studies

Quantified outcomes for named clients. Credibility currency.

Rubric
  • Client name, industry, challenge clearly stated
  • Quantified outcomes — numbers, not vibes
  • Quote from a named client contact
  • Solution narrative with enough detail to be credible, not so much it bores
  • Internal link to relevant solution / service page
Schema · Article (or custom) · Review if client permits
05 · SERVICE · CONVERSION05 / 13

Solution / service pages

One clear problem. Who it’s for. Who it isn’t. Proof. CTA.

Rubric
  • One clear problem it solves, stated upfront
  • Who it’s for, who it’s not for
  • How it works (3–5 steps / diagram)
  • Proof (logos, case studies, metrics)
  • Primary CTA (demo / contact)
  • FAQ section at the bottom with FAQPage schema for questions buyers actually ask
Schema · Service
06 · PRODUCT · COMMERCE06 / 13

Product pages (e-commerce)

Decision page. Price, availability, proof — all visible.

Rubric
  • Clear price, availability, variants
  • High-quality images + zoom + alt text
  • Reviews with AggregateRating schema
  • Specs, dimensions, materials
  • Delivery + return policy visible
  • Related products
Schema · Product + Offer (validated)
07 · PRICING · DECISION07 / 13

Pricing pages

The fork in the funnel. Comparison + trust signals + no dark patterns.

Rubric
  • Tier comparison as a real table
  • Primary action per tier
  • FAQ beneath (billing, trials, cancellation)
  • Trust signals (security, compliance badges)
  • Currency / region handling if international
  • No dark patterns — auditors should be skeptical of friction and misleading cues
Schema · Offer · Product · custom
08 · HUB · DISCOVERY08 / 13

Blog index / insights hub

Wayfinding. Filter, sort, find the article that matters.

Rubric
  • Filter by topic / tag
  • Reverse-chronological by default, but curated ‘featured’ slot
  • Each card: title, excerpt, author, date, estimated read time
  • Paginated, not infinite scroll (or both)
  • Dedicated RSS feed
Schema · ItemList / Blog
09 · PAID · CAMPAIGN09 / 13

Landing pages (paid campaigns)

Single purpose, single CTA. Message-match the ad.

Rubric
  • Single purpose, single CTA
  • Match the ad creative (message match)
  • No primary nav — remove escape hatches
  • Form: minimum necessary fields
  • UTM params handled and persisted
  • Excluded from main sitemap if short-lived; included if evergreen
Schema · WebPage · noindex if appropriate
10 · DOCS · UTILITY10 / 13

Documentation / knowledge base

Get answers fast. Search + hierarchy + feedback loop.

Rubric
  • Search prominent and working
  • Hierarchical left-nav
  • Versioning if applicable
  • Code blocks syntax-highlighted and copyable
  • Each article has a ‘was this helpful?’ feedback mechanism
Schema · TechArticle or Article
11 · TRUST · ENTITY11 / 13

About / team / trust pages

Establish who we are. Entity consistency for AI + search.

Rubric
  • Named leadership with photos, titles, bios, LinkedIn
  • Person schema on each leader
  • Company story with founding date, mission
  • Security / compliance page linked (SOC 2, ISO 27001, GDPR) if B2B
Schema · Organization (foundingDate, founder, address) + Person
12 · LEAD · INTAKE12 / 13

Contact / demo / lead-capture

Convert intent. Multiple modes + clear expectations.

Rubric
  • Multiple contact modes (form, email, phone, chat)
  • Expected response time stated
  • Form validated client-side AND server-side
  • Confirmation message AND confirmation email
  • Accessible form fields with labels
Schema · ContactPage
13 · LEGAL · COMPLIANCE13 / 13

Legal pages (privacy, terms, cookies)

Compliance + linkage. Not for indexing.

Rubric
  • Present, up-to-date, jurisdiction-appropriate
  • Linked from footer of every page
  • Cookie consent mechanism aligned with GDPR / ePrivacy where applicable
  • Not indexed usually (use noindex)
Schema · WebPage (typically noindex)
CONTENT AUDIT · BOOK

Want every URL on your site scored by type?

We inventory every indexed URL, classify it by type, run the matching rubric, and return a prune-keep-merge-rewrite roadmap organized by editorial priority.

Book content audit →